The Otter Valley Union Unified School Board discussed ways to cut costs at its Nov. 17 meeting but gave administrators no specific spending targets to guide preparation of the district’s fiscal year 2028 budget.
Finance Director Brenda Fleming said she was unsure what direction the board wanted to take. “You’re putting me in a place where I don’t know where you want me to go,” she told members.
With costs increasing and enrollment declining, board member Gabe McGuigan urged the district to find savings wherever possible. “We need to shed dollars. We need to shed dollars now,” he said, arguing that even relatively small reductions should be considered.
Other members emphasized the importance of protecting educational opportunities. Board member Fernanda Canales pointed out that the district already spends about $1,000 less per student than the statewide average.
Board members also explored potential savings on building maintenance and energy costs. Fleming said maintenance spending is already limited, and a board tour over the summer underscored the considerable maintenance needs across district buildings. She added that the district has made energy-saving improvements over the years, leaving few opportunities for substantial additional savings in the short term.
RNESU Superintendent Rene Sanchez said he saw no obvious opportunities for major savings without changing the district’s educational offerings. “I’m not seeing any big chunks. I’m seeing lots and lots of little slices and slivers in many places,” he said.
Class size poses challenge
Much of the budget discussion centered on new state minimum class size requirements, which pose challenges for rural schools with relatively few students. The requirements apply to average class sizes across grade levels or subject groups, not to each classroom individually.
At Otter Creek Academy, where some grades already share classrooms, administrators said meeting the requirements would be difficult even with further adjustments because of the small number of students in each grade.
Even larger schools face challenges. Lothrop Elementary School has 22 fourth graders divided into two classes of 11. The state’s minimum average for grades 2 to 5 is 12 students, but several board and administration members agreed a class size of 22 would be too large for that age group.
At Otter Valley Union High School, administrators said some upper-level science courses might need to be offered every other year to help manage class sizes.
Otter Valley Principal Michael Ruppel favored a gradual approach, noting that the state would not consider intervening until a district fell short of the requirements for three consecutive years.
The board also discussed the district’s elementary school choice policy, which allows families to enroll children outside their local school and has contributed to uneven enrollment, with small classes at Otter Creek Academy and high enrollment at Neshobe Elementary School. Canales suggested reconsidering the policy.
Board considers future of Whiting, Caverly buildings
The board voted to offer the former Whiting school building back to the town at the end of the current school year, with three members opposed.
The building, which previously housed a district preschool, is now used by A.R.K. Child Care, a privately operated child care and preschool provider, under a one-year agreement. A.R.K. pays rent that covers operating costs, but the district remains responsible for insurance, property taxes, and major repairs.
Under the district’s articles of agreement, Whiting can acquire the property for $1 if the district no longer needs it. The town would then take responsibility for maintaining the building.
Some members favored keeping the building during the state’s education restructuring process, suggesting higher rent from A.R.K. could help cover costs while preserving the building for possible future use.
Bertrand said Whiting has expressed informal interest in reclaiming the property.
The board postponed a decision on Pittsford’s Caverly building, which houses a district preschool, pending more information about preschool needs and the budget. Previous discussions about moving the preschool to Lothrop Elementary School drew public opposition and criticism.
College and career readiness show gains
Sanchez presented data showing substantial improvement in Otter Valley students’ readiness for college and careers, although the percentage of students going on to further education remains below the statewide average.
The percentage of students meeting the state’s college and career readiness assessment standards has nearly doubled in two years, rising from 37% in 2022-2023 to 56% in 2023-2024 and 73% in 2024-2025. The latest figure is nine percentage points above the statewide rate of 64%.
Sanchez attributed much of the improvement to career-related gains. Enrollment in education after high school also increased, though more modestly. The percentage of Otter Valley graduates enrolling within 16 months rose from 39% in 2022-2023 to 45% in 2024-2025, compared with 55% statewide.
Separate data covering seven graduating classes showed that female graduates enrolled in further education immediately after high school at a rate averaging 28 percentage points higher than male graduates.
Board member Kevin Thornton argued that the longstanding focus on expanding opportunities for girls has contributed to the neglect of boys’ educational needs and called for greater attention to the disparity.
Sanchez noted that college enrollment figures don’t capture graduates who enter the workforce, apprenticeships, military service, or other training programs.
Ruppel estimated that 3 to 10 students graduate each year without a clear plan for what comes next, out of a graduating class of 80 to 90.
“There are still a chunk of kids in our system that we worry about when they walk across the stage and we’re not quite sure what’s next for them,” he said.
Sanchez said the district hopes to combine state data with information from students and families to better understand graduates’ paths and identify those who may need additional support.
The board’s next meeting will be Tuesday, Dec. 1, at 6 p.m.





